Skip to content

Dessert · American

2-Ingredient Ice Cream Sandwiches

Oreos make the best ice cream sandwiches and this easy recipes proves it. Just remove the filling and add ice cream! One smart trick ensures maximum ice...

Prep
10 min
Total
1 hr 10 min
Serves
16

Growing up, I always associated summer with lazy afternoons spent at my Grandma Helen's lake house. Picture this,warm breezes, the sound of water lapping against the dock, and the echo of laughter from my cousins and me as we raced each other down the splintery wooden pier. Now, Grandma Helen wasn't much of a baker, but she sure knew how to keep us kids happy with treats that required no oven time whatsoever. One of my fondest memories was the day she unveiled what I thought was her most ingenious creation yet,ice cream sandwiches made from s. My eyes widened in astonishment as she pulled out a bag of those beloved sandwich cookies and a pint of creamy vanilla ice cream.

She simply twisted the cookies apart, replaced the sweet filling with a generous scoop of ice cream, and handed them out like treasures. Sitting on the grass with one of these homemade treats in hand, I felt like the luckiest kid alive. Grandma’s kitchen wasn’t exactly what you'd call fancy. She’d fill her pantry with practical essentials rather than exotic ingredients. But this ice cream sandwich recipe became a staple in our summer gatherings.

It didn't take much,just a bit of creativity and a love for seeing us kids smile from ear to ear as we indulged in those cool, creamy delights. Even now, whenever summer rolls around and the sun starts to shine a little brighter, I find myself craving those simple pleasures. There's something about the combination of a crispy and rich ice cream that feels just right when the temperatures rise. Whether it's a backyard barbecue with friends or a lazy Sunday afternoon, ice cream sandwiches feel just like a celebration. You might wonder why the combination of s and ice cream works so well.

It's all about the contrast and harmony at play. The cookies bring a delightful crunch and a deep cocoa flavor that pairs perfectly with a creamy ice cream filling. Every bite delivers a little bit of everything,sweetness, creaminess, a touch of saltiness, and the irresistible texture of the cookie. When you take that first bite and your teeth sink through the cold, creamy ice cream and meet the crisp , it's like a symphony of textures. The ice cream melts almost instantly, coating your tongue and blending with the slightly crumbly cookie, creating a flavor experience that's both nostalgic and satisfying.

The beauty of this recipe lies in its simplicity. With only two main ingredients, the quality of each component can really shine. Choosing a premium ice cream can make all the difference. The rich, creamy texture adds an indulgent touch that elevates this humble treat. You can experiment with flavors too,imagine a cookies and cream ice cream inside an shell, a kind of meta-experience where cookie meets ice cream and vice versa.

The smooth ice cream gets a natural stage to shine once enclosed by the protective shell, making each bite a delightful surprise. Now, onto some tips that will make your ice cream sandwich adventure smooth sailing. First, start with cookies that are fresh out of the package, so they have the right snap and sturdiness to hold the ice cream without crumbling apart.

Be gentle when you twist the open to preserve its integrity. If you're worried about broken cookies, having a few extras on hand can save the day. Choose an ice cream that's not too soft, freshly out of the freezer, to make it easier to scoop and more likely to hold its shape. Using a small cookie scoop can help you get just the right amount of ice cream without making a mess. And remember, once assembled, pop those sandwiches back into the freezer for a quick set before serving.

This ensures they won’t melt all over your hands the moment you dig in. The ice cream sandwich holds a special place in the heart of American dessert culture. With origins that trace back to the streets of New York in the late 1800s, these treats have evolved from simple scoops wedged between slabs of cake to the fancier, packaged versions we see today. Yet, in essence, the charm of an ice cream sandwich is its nostalgic appeal and the joy it brings with each bite. Making them at home brings back that childhood glee.

You’re not just serving dessert, you’re offering a slice of Americana, a piece of history wrapped in two cookies. In a way, making these sandwiches is about more than just dessert. It’s an ode to those carefree days of summer, a nod to creativity in the kitchen, and a celebration of simple pleasures that bring people together. Every time I make them, I feel that connection to my childhood, to Grandma Helen's kitchen, and to the joy of sharing something delightful with the people I love. It reminds me that sometimes, the simplest recipes are the ones that leave the biggest impact on our hearts, creating memories that last a lifetime.

Recipe

2-Ingredient Ice Cream Sandwiches

Prep
10 min
Total
1 hr 10 min
Serves
16

Ingredients

16 Servings

Method

  1. Step 1: Lay a piece of parchment paper at least 18 inches long on a flat surface. Run a dull knife around the edge of the pint to loosen the ice cream, and let it slip out onto the parchment. Cut the cylinder in half, lengthwise, and lay the two halves on their sides Next, to each other, end to end. Wrap the parchment around the ice cream and use your hands to gently and quickly form it into a log shape, approximately the diameter of one Oreo cookie. Wrap tightly and place in the freezer until frozen solid, at least 1 hour.

  2. Step 2: Working on a baking sheet that can fit in the freezer, twist the oreo cookie open and scrape the filling away with a dull knife. Discard filling, or share with a nearby child who is desperate for sugar. Repeat with remaining Oreos and arrange 16 cookie halves scraped side up in preparation for ice cream. Set aside.

  3. Step 3: Once the ice cream log is solid, remove from the freezer and cut into approximately 16 slices, each approximately ½ inch thick, using a thin, sharp knife.

  4. Step 4: Working quickly, place one ice cream disc on every upturned cookie, and top with the cookie’s other half. Place the baking sheet in the freezer to allow the ice cream to solidify before storing in an airtight container. Time eating the ice cream sandwiches based on your preference. For a tender cookie that still has some crunch, wait about 12 hours before eating. After 24 hours or more, the cookies will be very soft, more like the wafers of purchased ice cream sandwiches. The ice cream sandwiches are best consumed within 1 week. Love the recipe? Let us know with a rating and review!

Nutrition per serving

Calories
218
Protein
4 g
Carbs
30 g
Fat
10 g
Jump to recipe